Protagonist, villain, comic relief: who's who in a story
Change the setting, the period and the costumes, and stories remain populated by the same figures. There is someone who wants something, someone who walks alongside, someone who gets in the way, someone who makes us laugh and someone who teaches. These types repeat because each one fulfills a function the narrative needs, in a four-hundred-year-old novel or in this week's series. Knowing the five most common helps explain why certain stories hold our attention.
The protagonist: the one who wants something
The protagonist is not necessarily the strongest or the most likable character. It is the person whose desire sets the story in motion, and who reaches the end different from how they began. To recognize one, ask whose problem the plot needs to solve and who has the most to lose. Don Quixote, which Cervantes published in two parts, in 1605 and 1615, is the classic example: a gentleman who, after reading too many tales of chivalry, decides to become a knight-errant and sets out into the world in search of adventure. What he wants is impossible, and that is why the reader follows every step.
The best friend: the one who tags along and asks
The companion exists so that the protagonist has someone to talk to. They tag along, disagree and, quite often, ask the questions the audience would like to ask. Sancho Panza plays that role beside Don Quixote: where the knight sees giants, the squire sees windmills, and the contrast between the two holds the book up. In Arthur Conan Doyle's Sherlock Holmes stories, the narrator is Dr. Watson: he tells 56 of the detective's 60 stories, starting with the first, A Study in Scarlet, from 1887. Since he cannot keep up with Holmes's reasoning, he asks for explanations, and that is how the reader gets them.
The charming villain: the one with motive and charm
An antagonist who only wants to destroy gets tiresome quickly. The charming villain has a motive you can understand, even without agreeing, and a way of speaking that wins over the other characters and the audience. You recognize one when you catch yourself paying attention to them, almost rooting for them. Iago, from Shakespeare's Othello, is the model. Over the course of the play he is called honest more than twenty times by characters who trust him, and it is with that trust that he engineers Othello's ruin. Because Iago tells his plans directly to the audience, in soliloquies, those watching become accomplices of a sort.
The comic relief: the one who releases the tension
No audience can take tension without a break. The comic relief shows up to let the audience breathe, with a quip, a blunder or a badly timed remark, and by contrast makes the serious scenes that follow feel heavier. It is usually the one who says out loud what the others do not dare to say. Falstaff, the fat, hard-drinking, lying knight created by Shakespeare, is one of the most famous comic reliefs in theater. He appears in both parts of Henry IV and in The Merry Wives of Windsor. In Henry IV, his tavern scenes alternate with the intrigues of the court and give the plays a more human footing.
The mentor: the one who teaches and steps aside
The mentor knows what the protagonist does not know yet. They teach, hand over a piece of advice or a tool and, at some point, step aside, because the story only moves when the hero has to act alone. You can recognize one by the question left hanging: what now, without them? The word itself comes from a character. In Homer's Odyssey, Mentor is the friend to whom Odysseus, known as Ulysses in the Latin tradition, entrusts his household and his son Telemachus when he leaves for war. Later, it is in the guise of Mentor that the goddess Athena accompanies and advises the young man. The name only became a common noun much later, in the 18th century, because of a French novel from 1699, The Adventures of Telemachus, by Fénelon, in which Mentor plays a far bigger role than in Homer.
Why these types work
Each type answers a need of the person following the story. The protagonist gives us someone to root for, the companion gives a point of view close to our own, the villain provides the obstacle, the comic relief provides rest and the mentor gives meaning to what is learned. Together they form a map the audience recognizes within minutes.
Choosing a favorite says something about the person choosing. Some prefer the loyal companion because they value standing by someone, and some enjoy the villain because he does what nobody allows themselves to do. Good authors rarely deliver the pure type: what holds us is the surprise inside the mold, like the simple squire who at times shows more sense than his master.
In life, nobody is just one type
Characters are built to fulfill a function; people are not. On the same day, you can be the protagonist of your own job change, the companion in a friend's crisis and the comic relief at the family lunch. The types work as vocabulary for talking about stories and ways of acting, not as boxes to put someone in.
That is the spirit of our quiz about which TV show character you would be. In five questions, it arrives at one of four results, The Lead, The Best Friend, The Charming Villain or The Comic Relief, and builds a poster with your photo. Those are four of the five types in this article; only the mentor was left out. To see the role you take on outside fiction, the one about your type in the group chooses between The Leader, The Clown, The Group Parent and The Mysterious One. Both are entertainment, not psychological assessment.
Sources
The dates, names and numbers in this article were checked against these pages. Links open in a new tab.
- Real Academia Española: Don Quijote de la Mancha (Biblioteca Clásica Básica)
- Conan Doyle Estate: Dr. Watson
- Bardology: Othello (1604)
- Encyclopædia Britannica: Sir John Falstaff
- Encyclopædia Britannica (1911): Mentor
- Online Etymology Dictionary: mentor
Written for entertainment and general information. It does not replace professional advice.